Craig Wright loses U.K. case as judge rules Bitcoin file format can’t be copyrighted

Craig Wright has lost a case in the U.K. that could have allowed him to prevent the operation of Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash, as seen in a Feb. 7 court filing.

In his claim, Wright argued that Bitcoin SV — his minority fork of Bitcoin — is the original version of the Bitcoin blockchain. He argued that Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash re-use elements of Bitcoin to which he owns the rights whenever their software is executed. Wright, therefore, aimed to prevent the operation of those two chains.

Wright additionally claimed that the inclusion of the Bitcoin whitepaper in block 230,009 of Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash violates his copyright.

Judge James Mellor said that although Wright’s copyright claims over the Bitcoin whitepaper “raise serious issues to be tried,” today’s judgment only concerns whether Wright’s claims over Bitcoin’s file format constitute a serious issue to be tried.

Judge Mellor recognized Wright’s attempts to apply copyright to the Bitcoin File Format as a literary work. The judge noted that the term “literary work” could include a wide variety of subject matter, including computer software and non-human readable data.

However, it does not apply in this case. Judge Mellor said that, based on the evidence, merely running a Bitcoin node to create a new block in the Bitcoin File Format does not meet fixation or sufficient identifiability requirements. Copyright law cannot be applied to something whose “subject matter which is not expressed or fixed anywhere,” he said.

Judge Mellor said that to prevent default judgments against defendants, amended claims from Wright must remove references to copyright infringement on the Bitcoin File Format. Mellor additionally denied Wright permission to appeal today’s decision; Wright will first need to gain court permission if he wishes to do so.

Wright has repeatedly claimed that he is the creator of Bitcoin and the individual behind the pseudonym Satoshi Nakamoto.

Today’s case (IL-2022-000069) represents one of Wright’s many attempts to assert control over the Bitcoin landscape. It is separate from another case (BL-2021-000313) in which Wright intends to sue various Bitcoin developers on similar grounds. On Feb. 3, Judge Colin Birss in London’s Court of Appeals allowed the latter case to go to trial.

The latter case alleges that developers owe Wright an amount of Bitcoin — currently 111,000 BTC or $2.5 billion. No reference to any sum was made in today’s judgment.

Posted In: , , Legal, People

Bookmark (0)
ClosePlease loginn

Related Posts

Rocket League world champions TeamBDS partners with Xborg for web3 fan activations

Rocket League world champions TeamBDS partners with Xborg for web3 fan activations

Blockchain meets esports as XBorg Partners with Team BDS

Bookmark (0)
ClosePlease loginn
Citigroup believes CBDCs will lead the way to mass adoption

Citigroup believes CBDCs will lead the way to mass adoption

Citi said that mass adoption will happen when more than a billion people are using blockchain technology without knowing they’re using it.

Bookmark (0)
ClosePlease loginn
SBF pleads not guilty to all 13 federal indictments

SBF pleads not guilty to all 13 federal indictments

Sam Bankman-Fried’s trial is set to begin in October. He is also facing civil charges filed by the SEC and the CFTC.

Bookmark (0)
ClosePlease loginn
Cold wallet Ledger raises $108M as self-custody wallets gain popularity

Cold wallet Ledger raises $108M as self-custody wallets gain popularity

Hardware wallet ledger raised another $385 million in 2021, and its current valuation sits at $1.41 billion.

Bookmark (0)
ClosePlease loginn
Hong Kong signals licensing over 8 crypto companies by year-end

Hong Kong signals licensing over 8 crypto companies by year-end

Licenses will be issued under Hong Kong’s new crypto licensing regime, composed to support crypto firms looking to set up shop in the city.

Bookmark (0)
ClosePlease loginn
Coinbase, Kraken plan to continue operating in Canada as regulatory rules change

Coinbase, Kraken plan to continue operating in Canada as regulatory rules change

Kraken and Coinbase are among the first exchanges to officially declare their intent to remain in Canada.

Bookmark (0)
ClosePlease loginn

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *